By the Medsmingle Team · Updated 16 November 2026
For weight loss, low-carb and low-fat diets work about equally well. In the DIETFITS trial of 609 adults, people lost an average of 6.0 kg on a low-carb diet and 5.3 kg on a low-fat diet over a year, a difference too small to matter. The best diet is one you can stick with long term.
What the DIETFITS trial found
DIETFITS was a randomized trial published in the journal JAMA in 2018. It included 609 US adults with overweight or obesity, 57% of them women.
- People were randomly assigned to a low-fat or a low-carb diet for 12 months, with 22 diet support sessions.
- Both groups started by cutting fat or carbs to 20 grams a day for 2 months, then slowly added some back, to the lowest level they felt they could keep up.
- After a year, the low-carb group had lost an average of 6.0 kg and the low-fat group 5.3 kg. The 0.7 kg difference wasn’t meaningful.
- Results varied hugely from person to person in both groups, from losing 30 kg to gaining 10 kg.
Genes and insulin didn’t predict success
The researchers also tested whether a person’s genes or their insulin response to sugar could predict which diet would work best for them. Neither did. There was no evidence that either diet suits particular people better.
What both diets had in common
Both groups were taught to:
- eat plenty of vegetables
- keep sugar to a minimum
- focus on whole foods
- be physically active
This may matter more than the fat-to-carb split. Read more about sugary drinks, fiber and protein for weight loss.
How to choose
- Pick the approach that fits your tastes and routine. If you’d miss bread and rice, a lower-fat approach may be easier. If you’d rather cut back on starchy foods, a lower-carb approach may suit you better.
- Either way, you need a calorie deficit. Our guide to calorie deficits explains how to set one.
- Think long term. A balanced diet and physical activity you can maintain matter most. See how to keep weight off.
Check with your doctor first if
The trial didn’t include people with diabetes, uncontrolled high blood pressure or heart disease. If you have any of these, or take medicine for diabetes or blood pressure, talk to your doctor before making a big change to your diet.
Limitations
About 79% of people completed the trial, and the average weight loss was modest. It’s still unclear which personal traits predict who will lose more weight.
Frequently asked questions
Is low-carb better than low-fat for weight loss?
Not in the DIETFITS trial. After a year, weight loss was similar on both diets.
How much weight did people lose?
An average of 6.0 kg on the low-carb diet and 5.3 kg on the low-fat diet over 12 months.
Should I get a genetic test to choose a diet?
DIETFITS found that the genes it tested didn’t predict which diet worked better.
What matters most?
A plan you can stick with, built on vegetables, whole foods and less sugar, plus regular activity.
Sources
- Low fat or low carbohydrate diets seem just as effective for weight loss, NIHR Evidence, summarizing Gardner CD et al., JAMA (2018)
About Medsmingle
Medsmingle (medsmingle.com) shares clear, plain-English information on medicines and everyday health. Explore more health guides and the latest articles, read about us, or contact our team with a question.
This article is for general information only and isn’t a substitute for advice from a doctor or pharmacist. Don’t start, stop or change a medicine without talking to a qualified healthcare professional.